top of page

Avanti Press, Inc. Copyright Lawsuit: Schedule A Case No. 26-cv-12646

Writer: Rotek Law
Rotek Law
4 hours ago
6 min read

What Online Sellers Should Know About the Avanti Press Copyright Infringement Lawsuit Involving Greeting Card Artwork and Illustrations


On October 15, 2026, Avanti Press, Inc. filed a copyright infringement lawsuit in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois against online sellers identified in Schedule A. The case, numbered 1:26-cv-12646, concerns allegations involving the unauthorized reproduction and sale of artwork associated with Avanti Press, a company known for its greeting cards and illustrated stationery products.


Unlike trademark infringement lawsuits, which generally focus on unauthorized use of protected brand identifiers, copyright disputes concern the copying, distribution, or display of protected creative works. For online sellers offering greeting cards, illustrated merchandise, printed products, or other goods featuring third-party artwork, understanding the allegations and the scope of copyright protection may be important when evaluating potential legal exposure.


Case Information


Case Name: Avanti Press, Inc. v. The Partnerships and Unincorporated Associations Identified on Schedule A

Case Number: 1:26-cv-12646

Court: U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois

Filing Date: October 15, 2026

Plaintiff: Avanti Press, Inc.

Plaintiff's Counsel: Jiang IP LLC, with additional attorneys of record

Attorneys of Record: Keith A. Vogt, Yanling Jiang, Yi Bu, Monica Rita Martin, Christopher Romero, Cameron Eugene McIntyre, and Adam Grodman

Presiding Judge: Jeremy C. Daniel

Designated Magistrate Judge: Jeannice W. Appenteng

Nature of Action: Copyright Infringement

Works Involved: Avanti Press copyrighted artwork and illustrations

Significant Filing: Amended Schedule A filed October 15, 2026, Docket Entry No. 13

Case Status: Pending current docket verification


About the Plaintiff


Avanti Press, Inc. is an American greeting card company recognized for its illustrated cards, humorous designs, animal photography, and other creative stationery products.


The company develops and distributes greeting cards and related merchandise featuring original artistic works. Its products include cards depicting animals, humorous scenes, illustrated characters, and other visual compositions.


Creative works such as photographs, illustrations, and graphic designs may qualify for copyright protection when they meet applicable legal requirements.


Copyright protection can give rights holders exclusive rights to reproduce, distribute, display, and prepare derivative works based on protected material, subject to statutory limitations and exceptions.


For greeting card companies, unauthorized copying of artwork can present commercial concerns when the images are reproduced on competing products or merchandise sold through online marketplaces.


Avanti Press has pursued copyright enforcement actions against sellers accused of reproducing its artwork without permission.


What Are the Copyright Infringement Allegations?


The lawsuit concerns allegations that online sellers reproduced, displayed, distributed, or offered merchandise featuring artwork associated with Avanti Press without authorization.


The accused conduct may involve copying illustrations or images from greeting cards and reproducing those designs on merchandise sold through third-party e-commerce platforms.


Products implicated in artwork-related copyright disputes may include greeting cards, posters, prints, apparel, decorative products, and other goods featuring reproduced designs.


However, the exact creative works and products asserted in Case No. 26-cv-12646 must be confirmed through the complaint and its supporting exhibit.

Avanti Press filed its complaint with Exhibit 1 and a Schedule A list identifying the accused defendants.


On the same day, the company filed an amended Schedule A. The contents of that amended list and its effect on individual sellers have not been independently reviewed.


Under federal copyright law, a plaintiff generally must establish ownership of a valid copyright and copying of protected elements of the work.


Copyright protection does not extend to every idea, theme, or concept appearing in a creative work.


For example, the general idea of depicting an animal in a humorous situation is not itself protected in the same way as a particular original photograph, illustration, or artistic composition.


Whether a product infringes copyright depends on the specific work asserted, the allegedly copied elements, and any applicable defenses.


The filing of a complaint does not establish that the defendants are liable.


Can Sellers Use Artwork Found Online?


Online sellers sometimes obtain images from social media, search engines, supplier catalogs, design marketplaces, or other online sources.


However, the fact that an image is publicly available does not automatically mean that it is free to reproduce or sell on merchandise.


Copyright protection generally arises when an original work of authorship is fixed in a tangible medium, subject to applicable requirements.


A seller may therefore need permission to reproduce a protected image even if the image appears on a publicly accessible website.


Similarly, purchasing an item featuring artwork does not automatically transfer the copyright in the underlying design.


For example, buying a greeting card generally does not give the purchaser permission to scan the illustration and reproduce it on products offered for sale.

A seller should determine whether it owns the relevant copyright, has obtained an appropriate license, or can rely on a recognized limitation or exception.

Fair use may apply in certain circumstances, but its availability depends on a fact-specific analysis. Commercial reproduction of artwork on merchandise does not automatically qualify for fair use.


Sellers should preserve licensing records, original design files, supplier agreements, and other documentation relating to the creation or acquisition of artwork used in their products.


What Does the Amended Schedule A Mean?


On October 15, 2026, Avanti Press filed an amended Schedule A as Docket Entry No. 13.


Schedule A typically identifies the online storefronts or other defendants named in a lawsuit.


An amendment to this document may correct identifying information, modify listed storefronts, or make other changes to the defendant schedule.


However, the filing of an amended Schedule A does not necessarily mean the plaintiff dismissed the entire lawsuit or replaced every original defendant.

The precise effect of this particular amendment cannot be determined without reviewing the filed document and subsequent court orders.


Sellers who believe they may be involved should confirm whether their storefront appears on the operative defendant list and determine whether any later filings affect their party status.


How Could This Lawsuit Affect Online Sellers?


Schedule A copyright lawsuits may create legal and commercial consequences for businesses selling products through online marketplaces.


Depending on the court's orders and the circumstances of the case, potential consequences may include:


  • Removal or suspension of allegedly infringing product listings.

  • Restrictions affecting online marketplace storefronts or seller accounts.

  • Temporary restraints on funds associated with accused accounts, if ordered by the court.

  • Injunctions restricting further reproduction or distribution of specified artwork.

  • Claims for actual damages and profits or statutory damages where legally available.

  • Default judgments against defendants who fail to respond within applicable deadlines.


In copyright cases, statutory damages and attorneys' fees may depend on requirements involving registration, timing, and other applicable legal rules.

These consequences are not automatic.


The filing of a complaint does not establish that a temporary restraining order, preliminary injunction, or asset freeze has been entered.


Sellers should review the actual court orders and marketplace notifications before determining whether restrictions affect their businesses.


What Should Sellers Do If They Are Named in the Lawsuit?


Sellers who receive notice of the Avanti Press lawsuit should first determine whether their storefront or business appears in the applicable Schedule A defendant list.

They should review the complaint, identify the copyrighted works allegedly infringed, and compare those works with their product listings.


Relevant records may include original artwork files, supplier invoices, licensing agreements, design contracts, product photographs, purchase orders, and marketplace correspondence.


An attorney can help evaluate whether the plaintiff owns enforceable copyrights in the asserted works, whether the seller copied protected expression, and whether any defenses or limitations apply.


For products featuring illustrations or photographs, important questions may include who created the artwork, how the seller obtained it, whether a license authorized commercial reproduction, and whether the accused product incorporates protectable elements.


Sellers may also need to determine whether the amended Schedule A affects their status as defendants.


Depending on the facts, possible legal strategies may include contesting the allegations, negotiating a settlement, seeking relief from marketplace restrictions, or defending the claims in court.


Prompt attention to applicable notices and response deadlines is particularly important when business operations or access to marketplace funds may be affected.


Monitor the Case


For publicly available court filings, docket information, and procedural developments concerning this lawsuit, visit:



The public docket identifies an amended Schedule A filed on October 15, 2026. Sellers should consult the official court docket for subsequent amendments, court orders, and applicable response deadlines.


Named in a Schedule A Lawsuit?


If your Amazon, eBay, Etsy, or other online marketplace store has been named in the Avanti Press copyright lawsuit, understanding the allegations and available legal options can help you determine the appropriate next steps.


Rotek Law assists online sellers with intellectual property disputes, including Schedule A lawsuits involving copyright infringement, marketplace restrictions, and related enforcement actions.


Our legal team can review the claims against your store, assess potential defenses, and discuss available strategies for resolving the dispute.



Disclaimer


This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Case information may change as litigation progresses. Readers should verify current information through official court records. Reading this article does not establish an attorney-client relationship with Rotek Law.

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page